commit 8c33e34726cd98bc839fc832f073aab6bccb9965
parent e94a904d698cdc272cf263634c41112c50beb20b
Author: Lynn Foster <foster.j.lynn@gmail.com>
Date: Mon, 19 Aug 2019 15:56:00 -0500
more fixes (#568)
* added @bhaugen's text on independent view
* put in missing definitions, changed some statuses
* definition improvements from review
* better link for REA paper
Diffstat:
6 files changed, 104 insertions(+), 74 deletions(-)
diff --git a/docs/appendix/rea.md b/docs/appendix/rea.md
@@ -24,4 +24,4 @@ Extending REA from internal business systems into larger economic networks:
Besides REA, the other main core concept is [dependent demand](http://hillside.net/plop/plop97/Proceedings/haugen.pdf). We do event-driven Resource Requirements Planning based on that pattern.
-We have made some significant changes from what we might call "Classical REA", which you can read about [here](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1YpFaytWfeuGMxZWW6yY59ZTfL0PseAQ_LxqjjBhGogs/edit?usp=sharing). _Warning: that document will probably be interesting only to REA and Linked Data wonks..._-
\ No newline at end of file
+We have made some significant changes from what we might call "Classical REA", which you can read about [here](http://mikorizal.org/Fromprivateownershipaccountingtocommonsaccoun.html). _Warning: that document will probably be interesting only to REA and Linked Data wonks..._
diff --git a/docs/introduction/accounting.md b/docs/introduction/accounting.md
@@ -29,7 +29,7 @@ The standard set of accounting reports are needed by many organizations. A stand
-Moreover, General Ledgers and accounting reports can be created automatically for each agent in an economic network using the VF vocabulary.
+Moreover, General Ledgers and accounting reports can be created automatically for each agent in an economic network using the VF vocabulary. The accounting views use the Dependent or Individual Agent view of ValueFlows. See also [Independent vs Dependent views](https://valueflo.ws/introduction/core.html#independent-vs-dependent-views).
Accounting statements can also be updated instantly for each participant in any economic event as soon as the event is recorded. For example, consider an economic exchange, where one agent transfers some goods to another, and the other agent transfers some money in return. The inventory of the goods-providing agent will be instantly decremented, and the receiving agent's incremented. Likewise the money accounts of the money-providing and receiving agents will immediately change. Income statements, balance sheets, and cash flow reports can reflect the new changes immediately. The financial positions of each agent can always be up-to-date as of the last recorded event.
diff --git a/docs/introduction/core.md b/docs/introduction/core.md
@@ -4,8 +4,6 @@ The vocabulary has a core that would fit many different kinds of economic format
The core is based on the REA (Resource, Event, Agent) ontology. You can find all the details by following the [links here](https://valueflows.gitbooks.io/valueflows/content/appendix/rea.html).
-ValueFlows takes the "independent view" of REA, which is a neutral viewpoint in the "collaboration space" between agents. The "trading partner view" happens internal to one agent. For example, from one agent's viewpoint, the exchange may be a "purchase", from the other agent's viewpoint, it might be a "sale". From the neutral viewpoint, it is an exchange of resources, with usually at least two flows of resources, from different directions.
-
These are the main concepts in the REA ontology, as pictured in this [document](http://www.msu.edu/user/mccarth4/Alabama.doc):
@@ -14,6 +12,17 @@ Economic events are the movers and shakers. They say what is happening to econo
A key concept in REA is Duality, which means that each event wants one or more balancing events: in other words, some kind of reciprocity. REA uses an abstract word for this relationship in order to make the meaning configurable. The reciprocity does not need to happen at the same time, or in the same transaction. And it can have any logic that a network wants: payment in money, swap, earn credits, earn reputation points, share with the commons, from each according to ability and to each according to need, etc.
+### Independent vs Dependent views
+
+
+
+Conventional accounting always takes the view of an individual agent: often a company. REA, and ValueFlows, take an independent view, sometimes called a “collaboration space” or economic network or supply chain view. At the same time, derived from the independent view, REA and ValueFlows support each agent's own accounting view.
+
+For example, from one agent's viewpoint, the exchange may be a "purchase", from the other agent's viewpoint, it might be a "sale". From the neutral viewpoint, it is an exchange of resources, with usually at least two flows of resources, from different directions.
+
+For the individual agent’s accounting systems, assuming an Exchange of goods for money, when the goods are transferred from the seller to the purchaser, the purchaser’s Accounts Payable are increased (credited) and the seller’s Accounts Receivable are increased (debited). The independent view sees a transfer of goods from one agent to another.
+
+
### Levels of the ontology
All the levels of the REA ontology are similarly flexible and configurable:
diff --git a/release-doc-in-process/REAviews.png b/release-doc-in-process/REAviews.png
Binary files differ.
diff --git a/release-doc-in-process/REAviews.xml b/release-doc-in-process/REAviews.xml
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
+<mxfile modified="2019-08-19T15:33:46.397Z" host="www.draw.io" agent="Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Ubuntu; Linux x86_64; rv:68.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/68.0" etag="IzUW_bJvh5vM-DbSTrdy" version="11.1.5" type="google" pages="1"><diagram id="lgIhRmR16OGZFuEUa74A" name="Page-1">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</diagram></mxfile>+
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/release-doc-in-process/all_vf.TTL b/release-doc-in-process/all_vf.TTL
@@ -23,7 +23,7 @@
vf:Action a owl:Class ;
rdfs:label "vf:Action" ;
rdfs:subClassOf rdf:Property ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" ;
+ vs:term_status "testing" ;
rdfs:comment "An action verb defining the kind of event, commitment, or intent." .
vf:AgentRelationshipRole a owl:Class ;
@@ -67,7 +67,7 @@ vf:ScenarioDefinition a owl:Class ;
vf:Plan a owl:Class ;
rdfs:label "vf:Plan" ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" ;
+ vs:term_status "testing" ;
rdfs:comment "A logical collection of processes that constitute a body of scheduled work with defined deliverable(s)." .
vf:Intent a owl:Class ;
@@ -83,7 +83,7 @@ vf:Proposal a owl:Class ;
vf:ProposedIntent a owl:Class ;
rdfs:label "vf:ProposedIntent" ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "Supports including intents in multiple proposals, as well as a proposal including multiple intents." .
+ rdfs:comment "Represents many-to-many relationships between Proposals and Intents, supporting including intents in multiple proposals, as well as a proposal including multiple intents." .
vf:ProposedTo a owl:Class ;
rdfs:label "vf:ProposedTo" ;
@@ -98,7 +98,7 @@ vf:Commitment a owl:Class ;
vf:Satisfaction a owl:Class ;
rdfs:label "vf:Satisfaction" ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "A commitment or economic event that partially or fully satisfies one or more intents." .
+ rdfs:comment "Represents many-to-many relationships between intents and commitments or events that partially or full satisfy one or more intents." .
vf:Agreement a owl:Class ;
rdfs:label "vf:Agreement" ;
@@ -130,23 +130,23 @@ vf:EconomicEvent a owl:Class ;
vf:AgentRelationship a owl:Class ;
rdfs:label "vf:AgentRelationship" ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" ;
+ vs:term_status "testing" ;
rdfs:comment "An ongoing voluntary association between 2 agents of any kind." .
vf:Fulfillment a owl:Class ;
rdfs:label "vf:Fulfillment" ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "The quantity that the economic event fulfilled towards the commitment." .
+ rdfs:comment "Represents many-to-many relationships between commitments and economic events that fully or partially satisfy one or more commitments." .
vf:Claim a owl:Class ;
rdfs:label "vf:Claim" ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "A claim for a future economic event(s) in reciprocity for an economic event that already occurred." .
+ rdfs:comment "A claim for a future economic event(s) in reciprocity for an economic event that already occurred. For example, a claim for payment for goods received." .
vf:Settlement a owl:Class ;
rdfs:label "vf:Settlement" ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "The quantity that the economic event settled of the claim." .
+ rdfs:comment "Represents many-to-many relationships between claim and economic events that uflly or parially settle the one or more claims." .
vf:Appreciation a owl:Class ;
rdfs:label "vf:Appreciation" ;
@@ -162,7 +162,7 @@ vf:action
rdfs:label "action" ;
rdfs:domain [ owl:unionOf (vf:EconomicEvent vf:Commitment vf:Intent vf:RecipeFlow vf:Claim) ] ;
rdfs:range vf:Action ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" ;
+ vs:term_status "testing" ;
rdfs:comment "Relates a process input or output to a verb, such as consume, produce, work, improve, etc." .
vf:inputOf
@@ -170,16 +170,16 @@ vf:inputOf
rdfs:label "input of" ;
rdfs:domain [ owl:unionOf (vf:EconomicEvent vf:Commitment vf:Intent) ] ;
rdfs:range vf:Process ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "Relates an input flow to it's node." .
+ vs:term_status "testing" ;
+ rdfs:comment "Relates an input flow to it's process." .
vf:outputOf
a owl:ObjectProperty ;
rdfs:label "output of" ;
rdfs:domain [ owl:unionOf (vf:EconomicEvent vf:Commitment vf:Intent) ] ;
rdfs:range vf:Process ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "Relates an output flow to it's node." .
+ vs:term_status "testing" ;
+ rdfs:comment "Relates an output flow to it's process." .
vf:recipeInputOf
a owl:ObjectProperty ;
@@ -187,7 +187,7 @@ vf:recipeInputOf
rdfs:domain vf:RecipeFlow ;
rdfs:range vf:RecipeProcess ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "Relates an input flow to it's node in a recipe." .
+ rdfs:comment "Relates an input flow to it's process in a recipe." .
vf:recipeOutputOf
a owl:ObjectProperty ;
@@ -195,14 +195,14 @@ vf:recipeOutputOf
rdfs:domain vf:RecipeFlow ;
rdfs:range vf:RecipeProcess ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "Relates an output flow to it's node in a recipe." .
+ rdfs:comment "Relates an output flow to it's process in a recipe." .
vf:plannedWithin
a owl:ObjectProperty ;
rdfs:label "planned within" ;
rdfs:domain vf:Process ;
rdfs:range vf:Plan ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" ;
+ vs:term_status "testing" ;
rdfs:comment "The process with its inputs and outputs is part of the plan." .
vf:independentDemandOf
@@ -210,14 +210,15 @@ vf:independentDemandOf
rdfs:label "independent demand of" ;
rdfs:range vf:Plan ;
rdfs:domain vf:Commitment ;
- rdfs:comment "Represents a desired deliverable to the outside of this plan." .
+ vs:term_status "testing" ;
+ rdfs:comment "Represents a desired deliverable expected from this plan." .
vf:resourceInventoriedAs
a owl:ObjectProperty ;
rdfs:label "resource inventoried as" ;
rdfs:domain [ owl:unionOf (vf:Commitment vf:Intent vf:EconomicEvent) ] ;
rdfs:range vf:EconomicResource ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" ;
+ vs:term_status "testing" ;
rdfs:comment "Economic resource involved in the flow." .
vf:toResourceInventoriedAs
@@ -226,14 +227,14 @@ vf:toResourceInventoriedAs
rdfs:domain vf:EconomicEvent ;
rdfs:range vf:EconomicResource ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "Additional economic resource on the economic event when needed for receipt. Used when a transfer or move, or sometimes other actions, requires explicitly identifying an economic resource on the receiving side." .
+ rdfs:comment "Additional economic resource on the economic event when needed by the receiver. Used when a transfer or move, or sometimes other actions, requires explicitly identifying an economic resource on the receiving side." .
vf:relationship a owl:ObjectProperty ;
rdfs:label "relationship" ;
rdfs:domain vf:AgentRelationship ;
rdfs:range vf:AgentRelationshipRole ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "A kind of relationship that exists between 2 agents." .
+ vs:term_status "testing" ;
+ rdfs:comment "The role of an economic relationship that exists between 2 agents, such as member, trading partner." .
vf:appreciationOf
a owl:ObjectProperty ;
@@ -269,15 +270,15 @@ vf:subject a owl:ObjectProperty ;
rdfs:domain vf:AgentRelationship ;
rdfs:label "subject" ;
rdfs:range foaf:Agent ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "The subject of a relationship between 2 agents." .
+ vs:term_status "testing" ;
+ rdfs:comment "The subject of a relationship between 2 agents. For example, if Mary is a member of a group, then Mary is the subject." .
vf:object a owl:ObjectProperty ;
rdfs:domain vf:AgentRelationship ;
rdfs:label "object" ;
rdfs:range foaf:Agent ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "The object of a relationship between 2 agents." .
+ vs:term_status "testing" ;
+ rdfs:comment "The object of a relationship between 2 agents. For example, if Mary is a member of a group, then the group is the object." .
vf:inScopeOf a owl:ObjectProperty ;
rdfs:domain owl:Thing ;
@@ -305,7 +306,7 @@ vf:settles a owl:ObjectProperty ;
rdfs:domain vf:Settlement ;
rdfs:range vf:Claim ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "References a claim that fully or partially settled by the economic event." .
+ rdfs:comment "References a claim that is fully or partially settled by the economic event." .
vf:settledBy a owl:ObjectProperty ;
rdfs:label "settled by" ;
@@ -324,12 +325,14 @@ vf:containedIn a owl:ObjectProperty ;
vf:hasBeginning a owl:DatatypeProperty ;
rdfs:domain time:TemporalEntity ;
rdfs:range xsd:dateTimeStamp ;
+ vs:term_status "unstable" ;
owl:propertyChainAxiom (time:hasBeginning time:inXSDDateTimeStamp) ;
rdfs:comment "Specific time marking the exact beginning of flow or process".
vf:hasEnd a owl:DatatypeProperty ;
rdfs:domain time:TemporalEntity ;
rdfs:range xsd:dateTimeStamp ;
+ vs:term_status "unstable" ;
owl:propertyChainAxiom (time:hasEnd time:inXSDDateTimeStamp) ;
rdfs:comment "Specific time marking the exact end of flow or process".
@@ -338,14 +341,14 @@ vf:accountingQuantity a owl:ObjectProperty ;
rdfs:domain vf:EconomicResource ;
rdfs:range qudt:QuantityValue ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "The current amount and unit of the economic resource for which the agent has primary rights and responsibilities, sometimes thought of as ownership. This can be stored or derived from economic events affecting the resource." .
+ rdfs:comment "The current amount and unit of the economic resource for which the agent has primary rights and responsibilities, sometimes thought of as ownership. This can be either stored or derived from economic events affecting the resource." .
vf:onhandQuantity a owl:ObjectProperty ;
rdfs:label "onhand quantity" ;
rdfs:domain vf:EconomicResource ;
rdfs:range qudt:QuantityValue ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "The current amount and unit of the economic resource which is under direct control of the agent. It may be more or less than the accounting quantity. This can be stored or derived from economic events affecting the resource." .
+ rdfs:comment "The current amount and unit of the economic resource which is under direct control of the agent. It may be more or less than the accounting quantity. This can be either stored or derived from economic events affecting the resource." .
vf:resourceQuantity a owl:ObjectProperty ;
rdfs:label "resource quantity" ;
@@ -366,7 +369,7 @@ vf:availableQuantity a owl:ObjectProperty ;
rdfs:domain vf:Intent ;
rdfs:range qudt:QuantityValue ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "The quantity of the offered or requested resource currently available." .
+ rdfs:comment "The quantity of the offered resource currently available." .
vf:unitBased a owl:DatatypeProperty ;
rdfs:label "unit based" ;
@@ -405,11 +408,13 @@ vf:atLocation a owl:ObjectProperty ;
vf:image a owl:DatatypeProperty ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:label "image" .
+ rdfs:label "image" ;
+ rdfs:comment "The uri to an image relevant to the entity, such as a logo, avatar, photo, diagram, etc." .
vf:uri a owl:DatatypeProperty ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:label "uri" .
+ rdfs:label "uri" ;
+ rdfs:comment "The web address relevant to the entity." .
vf:name a owl:DatatypeProperty ;
rdfs:label "name" ;
@@ -499,14 +504,14 @@ vf:reciprocal
rdfs:domain vf:ProposedIntent ;
rdfs:range xsd:boolean ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "This is a reciprocal intent of this proposal, not primary. Not meant to be part of intent matching." .
+ rdfs:comment "This is a reciprocal intent of this proposal, not primary. Not meant to be used for intent matching." .
vf:finished a owl:DatatypeProperty ;
rdfs:domain [ owl:unionOf (vf:Commitment vf:Process vf:Intent vf:Claim) ] ;
rdfs:label "finished" ;
rdfs:range xsd:boolean ;
vs:term_status "testing" ;
- rdfs:comment "The commitment or intent or process is complete or not." .
+ rdfs:comment "The commitment or intent or process is complete or not. This is irrespective of if the original goal has been met, and indicates that no more will be done." .
vf:substitutable a owl:DatatypeProperty ;
rdfs:label "substitutable" ;
@@ -529,14 +534,6 @@ vf:unitOfEffort a owl:ObjectProperty ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
rdfs:comment "The unit used for use or work or sometimes cite actions." .
-vf:durationMultiplier
- a owl:DatatypeProperty ;
- rdfs:label "duration multiplier" ;
- rdfs:domain vf:RecipeProcess ;
- rdfs:range xsd:float ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "The multiplier for duration based on capacities for the recipe." .
-
vf:basedOn
a owl:ObjectProperty ;
rdfs:label "based on" ;
@@ -548,10 +545,10 @@ vf:basedOn
vf:classifiedAs
a owl:ObjectProperty ;
rdfs:label "classified as" ;
- rdfs:domain owl:Thing ;
+ rdfs:domain [ owl:unionOf (vf:Process vf:EconomicResource) ] ;
rdfs:range owl:Thing ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "References a concept in a common taxonomy or other classification scheme for purposes of categorization or grouping." .
+ rdfs:comment "References one or more concepts in a common taxonomy or other classification scheme for purposes of categorization or grouping." .
vf:resourceClassifiedAs
a owl:ObjectProperty ;
@@ -638,7 +635,7 @@ vf:clauseOf a owl:ObjectProperty ;
rdfs:domain vf:Commitment ;
rdfs:range vf:Agreement ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:comment "This commitment is part of the agreement, which could not exist without it." .
+ rdfs:comment "This commitment is part of the agreement." .
vf:realizationOf a owl:ObjectProperty ;
rdfs:label "realization of" ;
@@ -659,82 +656,104 @@ vf:mappableAddress a owl:ObjectProperty ;
vf:increment a vf:Action ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:label "increment" .
+ rdfs:label "increment" ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
vf:decrement a vf:Action ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:label "decrement" .
+ rdfs:label "decrement" ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
vf:dropoff a vf:Action ;
rdfs:label "dropoff" ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" .
+ vs:term_status "unstable" ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
vf:pickup a vf:Action ;
rdfs:label "pickup" ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" .
+ vs:term_status "unstable" ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
vf:consume a vf:Action ;
rdfs:label "consume" ;
vs:term_status "testing" ;
- rdfs:subPropertyOf vf:decrement .
+ rdfs:subPropertyOf vf:decrement ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
vf:use a vf:Action ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:label "use" .
+ vs:term_status "testing" ;
+ rdfs:label "use" ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
vf:work a vf:Action ;
vs:term_status "testing" ;
- rdfs:label "work" .
+ rdfs:label "work" ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
vf:cite a vf:Action ;
vs:term_status "testing" ;
- rdfs:label "cite" .
+ rdfs:label "cite" ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
vf:produce a vf:Action ;
rdfs:label "produce" ;
vs:term_status "testing" ;
- rdfs:subPropertyOf vf:increment .
+ rdfs:subPropertyOf vf:increment ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
vf:accept a vf:Action ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:label "accept" .
+ vs:term_status "testing" ;
+ rdfs:label "accept" ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
vf:modify a vf:Action ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:label "modify" .
+ vs:term_status "testing" ;
+ rdfs:label "modify" ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
vf:pass a vf:Action ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:label "pass" .
+ rdfs:label "pass" ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
vf:fail a vf:Action ;
vs:term_status "unstable" ;
- rdfs:label "fail" .
+ rdfs:label "fail" ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
-vf:service a vf:Action ;
- vs:term_status "testing" ;
- rdfs:label "service" .
+vf:deliver-service a vf:Action ;
+ vs:term_status "unstable" ;
+ rdfs:label "deliver-service" ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
vf:raise a vf:Action ;
+ vs:term_status "unstable" ;
rdfs:label "raise" ;
- rdfs:subPropertyOf vf:increment .
+ rdfs:subPropertyOf vf:increment ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
vf:lower a vf:Action ;
+ vs:term_status "unstable" ;
rdfs:label "lower" ;
- rdfs:subPropertyOf vf:decrement .
+ rdfs:subPropertyOf vf:decrement ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
vf:transfer-complete a vf:Action ;
rdfs:label "transfer-complete" ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" .
+ vs:term_status "unstable" ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
vf:transfer-all-rights a vf:Action ;
rdfs:label "transfer-all-rights" ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" .
+ vs:term_status "unstable" ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
vf:transfer-custody a vf:Action ;
rdfs:label "transfer-custody" ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" .
+ vs:term_status "unstable" ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
vf:move a vf:Action ;
rdfs:label "move" ;
- vs:term_status "unstable" .
+ vs:term_status "unstable" ;
+ rdfs:comment " ." .
