order-fulfillment.md (13934B)
1 ## Snippet to study fulfillment of process and exchange related commitments 2 3 This initial version of the picture does not have any of the proposed differentiation between process-related and exchange-related commitments. The yaml has some of that. It is all here to facilitate discussion on the issue, see what it actually might look like. 4 5 Use case: 6 * The bakery orders 2 bushels of apples from the fruit farm in exchange for 1000 Faircoin. 7 * The fruit farm delivers 1.5 bushels of apples (all they had left) to the bakery. 8 * The fruit farm does a day of harvesting apples. 9 * The bakery order another .5 bushel of apples, since they have a delivery coming anyhow. 10 * The fruit farm delivers 1 bushel of apples, so that all orders are fulfilled. 11 * The bakery pays for all the apples at once, with 1250 Faircoin. 12 13  14 15 #### Resources before 16 ``` yaml 17 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 18 '@id': https://fruitfarm.example/apples 19 '@type': vf:EconomicResource 20 'vf:resourceCategory': https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q89#apple-category 21 'skos:note': This only has a resource category, the fruitfarm does not keep inventory records on its apples. 22 ``` 23 ``` yaml 24 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 25 '@id': https://bakery.example/apples 26 '@type': vf:EconomicResource 27 'vf:resourceCategory': https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q89#apple-category 28 'vf:quantity': 29 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 30 'qudt:unit': unit:Bushel 31 'qudt:numericValue': .5 32 ``` 33 ``` yaml 34 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 35 '@id': https://chain.fair-coin.org/address/fVRdLE87ywagHTLkWf7B4y2f3DU1K59nFE/# 36 '@type': vf:EconomicResource 37 'vf:resourceCategory': https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q8142#currency 38 'vf:resourceModel': https://ocp.freedomcoop.eu/accounting/resource-type/26/#Faircoin-address #best way to do currency? 39 'vf:quantity': 40 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 41 'qudt:unit': unit:Faircoin 42 'qudt:numericValue': 20433 43 'skos:note': the bakery faircoin address (account) 44 ``` 45 ``` yaml 46 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 47 '@id': https://chain.fair-coin.org/address/fFdw8QyWwJjHVPnjkWkYAYbQ1GxmT5JA7w/# 48 '@type': vf:EconomicResource 49 'vf:resourceCategory': https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q8142#currency 50 'vf:resourceModel': https://ocp.freedomcoop.eu/accounting/resource-type/26/#Faircoin-address #best way to do currency? 51 'vf:quantity': 52 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 53 'qudt:unit': unit:Faircoin 54 'qudt:numericValue': 5400 55 'skos:note': the fruit farm faircoin address (account) 56 ``` 57 #### The bakery orders apples from the fruit farm 58 ``` yaml 59 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 60 '@id': https://fruitfarm.example/rf789f7f#exchange 61 '@type': vf:ExchangeAgreement 62 'skos:note': bakery orders apples in exchange for Faircoin 63 'vf:commitments': 64 - '@id': '#unload-1' 65 '@type': vf:Commitment 66 'vf:committedAction': vf:unload 67 'vf:involves': https://fruitfarm.example/apples 68 'vf:committedQuantity': 69 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 70 'qudt:unit': unit:Bushel 71 'qudt:numericValue': 2 72 'vf:provider': https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 73 'vf:receiver': https://customer.example/#agent 74 - '@id': '#receive-3' 75 '@type': vf:Commitment 76 'vf:committedAction': vf:transfer #just trying this out; could also be vf:receive 77 'vf:resourceCategory': https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q8142#currency #don't even really need this 78 'vf:committedQuantity': 79 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 80 'qudt:unit': unit:Faircoin 81 'qudt:numericValue': 1000 82 'vf:provider: https://bakery.example/#agent 83 'vf:receiver': https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 84 ``` 85 #### Fruit Farm delivers some of the apples 86 ``` yaml 87 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 88 '@id': https://fruitfarm.example/rf782334df#process 89 '@type': vf:Transportation 90 'vf:input': 91 - '@id': '#work-1' 92 '@type': vf:EconomicEvent 93 'vf:action': vf:work 94 'vf:affectedQuantity': 95 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 96 'qudt:unit': unit:Hour 97 'qudt:numericValue': .5 98 'vf:provider': https://bob.example/#agent 99 'vf:receiver': https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 100 - '@id': '#load-1' 101 '@type': vf:EconomicEvent 102 'vf:action': vf:load 103 'vf:affectedQuantity': 104 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 105 'qudt:unit': unit:Bushel 106 'qudt:numericValue': 1.5 107 'vf:provider': https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 108 'vf:receiver': https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 109 'vf:output': 110 - '@id': '#unload-1' 111 '@type': vf:EconomicEvent 112 'vf:action': vf:unload # deliver sounds better in this use case 113 'vf:affects': https://bakery.example/apples 114 'vf:action': vf:unload 115 'vf:affectedQuantity': 116 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 117 'qudt:unit': unit:Bushel 118 'qudt:numericValue': 1.5 119 'vf:provider: https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 120 'vf:receiver': https://bakery.example/#agent 121 ``` 122 ``` yaml 123 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 124 '@id': https://fruitfarm.example/rf78233ccc#fulfillment 125 '@type': vf:TransferFulfillment 126 'vf:fulfillsTransfer': https://fruitfarm.example/rf789f7f#unload-1 #commitment 127 'vf:fulfilledBy': https://fruitfarm.example/rf782334df#unload-1 #event 128 'vf:fulfilledQuantity': 129 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 130 'qudt:unit': unit:Bushel 131 'qudt:numericValue': 1.5 132 ``` 133 134 #### Fruit Farm plans and harvests more apples 135 ``` yaml 136 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 137 '@id': https://fruitfarm.example/rf78234uj8#process 138 '@type': vf:Transformation 139 'skos:note': harvest apples 140 'vf:input': 141 - '@id': '#commitment-1' 142 '@type': vf:Commitment 143 'vf:action': vf:work 144 'vf:affectedQuantity': 145 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 146 'qudt:unit': unit:Hour 147 'qudt:numericValue': 8 148 'vf:provider': https://alice.example/#agent 149 'vf:receiver': https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 150 - '@id': '#work-1' 151 '@type': vf:EconomicEvent 152 'vf:action': vf:work 153 'vf:affectedQuantity': 154 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 155 'qudt:unit': unit:Hour 156 'qudt:numericValue': 8 157 'vf:provider': https://alice.example/#agent 158 'vf:receiver': https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 159 'vf:fulfills': https://fruitfarm.example/rf78234uj8#commitment-1 160 'vf:output': 161 - '@id': '#commitment-2' 162 '@type': vf:EconomicEvent 163 'vf:action': vf:produce 164 'vf:affects': https://fruitfarm.example/apples 165 'vf:affectedQuantity': 166 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 167 'qudt:unit': unit:Bushel 168 'qudt:numericValue': 12 169 'vf:provider: https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 170 'vf:receiver': https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 171 - '@id': '#produce-1' 172 '@type': vf:EconomicEvent 173 'vf:action': vf:produce 174 'vf:affects': https://fruitfarm.example/apples 175 'vf:affectedQuantity': 176 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 177 'qudt:unit': unit:Bushel 178 'qudt:numericValue': 15 179 'vf:provider: https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 180 'vf:receiver': https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 181 'vf:fulfills': https://fruitfarm.example/rf78234uj8#commitment-2 182 ``` 183 #### The bakery decides to order some more apples as long as they are still due a delivery 184 ``` yaml 185 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 186 '@id': https://fruitfarm.example/rf78as88#exchange 187 '@type': vf:ExchangeAgreement 188 'skos:note': bakery ordersapples in exchange for Faircoin 189 'vf:commitments': 190 - '@id': '#unload-1' 191 '@type': vf:Commitment 192 'vf:committedAction': vf:unload 193 'vf:involves': https://fruitfarm.example/apples 194 'vf:committedQuantity': 195 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 196 'qudt:unit': unit:Bushel 197 'qudt:numericValue': .5 198 'vf:provider: https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 199 'vf:receiver': https://customer.example/#agent 200 - '@id': '#receive-3' 201 '@type': vf:Commitment 202 'vf:committedAction': vf:transfer #just trying this out; could also be vf:receive 203 'vf:resourceCategory': https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q8142#currency #don't even really need this 204 'vf:committedQuantity': 205 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 206 'qudt:unit': unit:Faircoin 207 'qudt:numericValue': 250 208 'vf:provider: https://bakery.example/#agent 209 'vf:receiver': https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 210 ``` 211 212 #### Fruit farm plans and delivers the rest of the apples 213 ``` yaml 214 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 215 '@id': https://fruitfarm.example/rf782334df#process 216 '@type': vf:Transportation 217 'vf:input': 218 - '@id': '#commitment-1' 219 '@type': vf:Commitment 220 'vf:action': vf:load 221 'vf:affectedQuantity': 222 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 223 'qudt:unit': unit:Bushel 224 'qudt:numericValue': 1 225 'vf:provider': https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 226 'vf:receiver': https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 227 - '@id': '#load-1' 228 '@type': vf:EconomicEvent 229 'vf:action': vf:load 230 'vf:affectedQuantity': 231 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 232 'qudt:unit': unit:Bushel 233 'qudt:numericValue': 1 234 'vf:provider': https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 235 'vf:receiver': https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 236 'vf:fulfills': https://fruitfarm.example/rf782334df#commitment-1 237 'vf:output': 238 - '@id': '#commitment-2' 239 '@type': vf:Commitment 240 'vf:action': vf:unload # deliver sounds better in this use case 241 'vf:affects': https://bakery.example/apples 242 'vf:action': vf:unload 243 'vf:affectedQuantity': 244 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 245 'qudt:unit': unit:Bushel 246 'qudt:numericValue': 1 247 'vf:provider: https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 248 'vf:receiver': https://bakery.example/#agent 249 - '@id': '#unload-1' 250 '@type': vf:EconomicEvent 251 'vf:action': vf:unload # deliver sounds better in this use case 252 'vf:affects': https://bakery.example/apples 253 'vf:action': vf:unload 254 'vf:affectedQuantity': 255 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 256 'qudt:unit': unit:Bushel 257 'qudt:numericValue': 1 258 'vf:provider: https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 259 'vf:receiver': https://bakery.example/#agent 260 'vf:fulfills': https://fruitfarm.example/rf782334df#commitment-2 261 ``` 262 ``` yaml 263 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 264 '@id': https://fruitfarm.example/rfdfs7789d#fulfillment 265 '@type': vf:TransferFulfillment 266 'vf:fulfillsTransfer': https://fruitfarm.example/rf789f7f#unload-1 #commitment 267 'vf:fulfilledBy': https://fruitfarm.example/rf782334df#unload-1 #event 268 'vf:fulfilledQuantity': 269 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 270 'qudt:unit': unit:Bushel 271 'qudt:numericValue': .5 272 ``` 273 ``` yaml 274 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 275 '@id': https://fruitfarm.example/rfdfs778ww#fulfillment 276 '@type': vf:TransferFulfillment 277 'vf:fulfillsTransfer': https://fruitfarm.example/rf78as88#unload-1 #commitment 278 'vf:fulfilledBy': https://fruitfarm.example/rf782334df#unload-1 #event 279 'vf:fulfilledQuantity': 280 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 281 'qudt:unit': unit:Bushel 282 'qudt:numericValue': .5 283 ``` 284 #### The bakery pays for all the apples 285 ``` yaml 286 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 287 '@id': https://bakery.example/erw890e8r#transfer 288 '@type': vf:Transfer #???? one event? two events? do like issue/receive? 289 'vf:affectedQuantity': 290 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 291 'qudt:unit': unit:Faircoin 292 'qudt:numericValue': 1250 293 'vf:provider': https://bakery.example/#agent 294 'vf:receiver': https://fruitfarm.example/#agent 295 'vf:give': 296 - '@id': '#give-1' 297 '@type': vf:EconomicEvent 298 'vf:action': vf:give 299 'vf:affects': '@id': https://chain.fair-coin.org/address/fVRdLE87ywagHTLkWf7B4y2f3DU1K59nFE/# 300 'vf:take': 301 - '@id': '#take-1' 302 '@type': vf:EconomicEvent 303 'vf:action': vf:take 304 'vf:affects': '@id': https://chain.fair-coin.org/address/fFdw8QyWwJjHVPnjkWkYAYbQ1GxmT5JA7w/# 305 ``` 306 ``` yaml 307 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 308 '@id': https://fruitfarm.example/rfdfwerw3#fulfillment 309 '@type': vf:TransferFulfillment 310 'vf:fulfillsTransfer': https://fruitfarm.example/rf789f7f#receive-3 #commitment 311 'vf:fulfilledBy': https://bakery.example/erw890e8r#take-1 #event 312 'vf:fulfilledQuantity': 313 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 314 'qudt:unit': unit:Faircoin 315 'qudt:numericValue': 1000 316 ``` 317 ``` yaml 318 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 319 '@id': https://fruitfarm.example/rfdfwerw4#fulfillment 320 '@type': vf:TransferFulfillment 321 'vf:fulfillsTransfer': https://fruitfarm.example/rf78as88#receive-3 #commitment 322 'vf:fulfilledBy': https://bakery.example/erw890e8r#take-1 #event 323 'vf:fulfilledQuantity': 324 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 325 'qudt:unit': unit:Faircoin 326 'qudt:numericValue': 250 327 ``` 328 329 #### Resources after 330 ``` yaml 331 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 332 '@id': https://fruitfarm.example/apples 333 '@type': vf:EconomicResource 334 'vf:resourceCategory': https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q89#apple-category 335 'skos:note': This only has a resource category, the fruitfarm does not keep inventory records on its apples. 336 ``` 337 ``` yaml 338 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 339 '@id': https://bakery.example/apples 340 '@type': vf:EconomicResource 341 'vf:resourceCategory': https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q89#apple-category 342 'vf:quantity': 343 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 344 'qudt:unit': unit:Bushel 345 'qudt:numericValue': 3 346 ``` 347 ``` yaml 348 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 349 '@id': https://chain.fair-coin.org/address/fVRdLE87ywagHTLkWf7B4y2f3DU1K59nFE/# 350 '@type': vf:EconomicResource 351 'vf:resourceCategory': https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q8142#currency 352 'vf:resourceModel': https://ocp.freedomcoop.eu/accounting/resource-type/26/#Faircoin-address #best way to do currency? 353 'vf:quantity': 354 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 355 'qudt:unit': unit:Faircoin 356 'qudt:numericValue': 19183 357 'skos:note': the bakery faircoin address (account) 358 ``` yaml 359 '@context': https://w3id.org/valueflows/v1 360 '@id': https://chain.fair-coin.org/address/fFdw8QyWwJjHVPnjkWkYAYbQ1GxmT5JA7w/# 361 '@type': vf:EconomicResource 362 'vf:resourceCategory': https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q8142#currency 363 'vf:resourceModel': https://ocp.freedomcoop.eu/accounting/resource-type/26/#Faircoin-address #best way to do currency? 364 'vf:quantity': 365 '@type': qudt:QuantityValue 366 'qudt:unit': unit:Faircoin 367 'qudt:numericValue': 6650 368 'skos:note': the fruit farm faircoin address (account) 369 ```